A bit delayed, but here goes. The trip was great - a total of about 740 miles, including some of the best riding in NZ, like the Forgotten World Highway, which is just under 100 miles of twisting, turning road, with some tight corners turning back on themselves and signposted at 10mph. Another great thing is that it was pretty much deserted - very light traffic due to being midweek.
Anyway, on the trip down, I have maybe an extra 90-100kg of weight, with the wife and luggage aboard. The shock's performance was rather disappointing - it felt a bit wooden and seemed to get worse as the ride progressed.
At the workshop, the removal took a speedy 20 minutes, helped by having done the practice run, and having the bike up on a bench so it was easier to access things.
When Dr Bob took the shock apart and measured everything, it turned out that the shock tube was identical in diameter to an Ohlins commonly used on the VFR. He was impressed by the quality of the components, but somewhat bemused by the shim stack, and by the workings of the compression damping bleed screw, and showed me that the porting holes in the piston were around half the total area of those of the comparable Ohlins. So... we decided between us that he'd chuck all the internals, and just rebuild it as an Ohlins. The rider was that because the remote reservoir and compression damper was so different, he'd leave that alone, so "This will either all work, or I'll have to take it all out and start again". Gulp...
I asked about just fitting the Ohlins remote res, and he said that would cost around NZ$880; given that the "Roadline" Ohlins for the VFR was only around NZ$1100, this was a crazy idea.
We were both surprised that the spring (which he said was very good quality), was ideal for my weight (83kg). He tested it, and the "900#" spring actually measured 859#.
The 10-shim stack was replaced with an 8-shim Ohlins one. Dunno what the difference in shims was, as Dr Bob didn't measure them.
Everything was carefully cleaned, measured, fitted, and the oil (Redline? ATF? Raspberry cordial?) was replaced with $50/litre Ohlins oil, of the exact kind in the Ohlins used in MotoGP bikes.
I replaced the shock in the VFR, losing the top nut into the V4 Black Hole again, so Dr Bob machined me a similar one, whereupon the other one fell out on the floor, so I've a spare for next time. The sag was set up for my weight, and off went Dr Bob for an extended test ride around Taranaki, never to be seen again...
... for about 20 minutes or so. "It feels pretty damned good to me! Your turn! You'll notice it feels like it's working more in the top of its stroke, but even though it seems more compliant, it's actually effectively stiffer."
I agreed, and when we (my wife and I) piled all our gear on and did more sight-seeing/riding, the Elkins/Ohlka felt even better: much more compliant, and VERY responsive to changes in preload adjustment. This went along with what Dr Bob said: "When you're setting the preload for two-up, you may feel like you need to dial in more damping, especially rebound, but in fact, as you get the shock operating in the right range, there's less tendency to rebound anyway." And so it proved.
So, I'm now very pleased. The Elkins/Ohlka now feels like it matches the Ohlins/Racetech front end, rather than fighting it to some extent, is much plusher when carrying extra weight, and much more responsive to adjustment. I haven't even had to touch the damping yet! Dr Bob set it up with the original settings, then apart from one extra click of rebound, that was it!