Below is a link for a road test for the 2012 VFR1200. It's a good, positive article. It briefly explains how Honda mismanaged information about the new VRF1200 as opposed to how they failed to meet (the public) expectations.
Also, I've attached a link that shows how the VFR1200 favorably stacks up against the BMW K1300S. (Note: especially see the video)
How does that compare to your 5th Gen? Seems like your CO altitude would help mileage. I always get better mileage in the mountains.
The 800 was more consistent no matter how I flogged it, the 1200 is completely dependent on how much I rev it, spirted twisties in 3rd 4th gear reved up for pulling out of corners will put me in the 31mpg range. Interstate cruising I get good milage. As you can see from the history data its all over the place 31 - 50 averaging 39mpg but conistantly up over 40mpg in the high country.