I recently did my first chain with a rivet-style masterlink and after a few hundred miles, POW! I no longer have a chain on my bike and I'm left sitting. I used Sun Star sprockets front and rear with an RK 530XSO chain. I flared the pins to .4 mm give or take a thousandth, RK recommends anywhere between 0.152 to .5 MM. I inspected the newly flared rivets for cracks or stress marks and they looked fine. I also made sure the plate wasn't pressed on too far by comparing the masterlink's overall width with the other links. The chain was adjusted properly at just under 1 1/4 ". I have ordered another masterlink to give it another shot. Luckily the new chain (and me) survived the incident with hardly a scratch. I have scoured the web looking for answers to no avail. Did I miss something or was this an unavoidable occurrence?
Of course I didn't take any pictures. DOH! That would be far too logical. It did look exactly like RK's FAQ picture. I spent a good while measuring and comparing the pics. On account of my anal retentiveness.
I've never had a rivet link fail. It must have been a freak thing, because it sounds like you did everything right. I can't see lightning striking twice.
The chain broke at the master link. It's completely gone, which leads me to believe the side plate came off and the link worked out. When the new link comes in I'm gonna re-install the chain with an extra set of eyes watching to make sure I don't miss something. I'm almost positive this was operator error, I just can't pin down what I did wrong.